The bracket is out, the regionals are set, and once again, the NCAA Division I Softball Committee has sparked more than a few eye rolls with their seeding decisions. Sixty-four teams are officially on the road to Oklahoma City, where Devon Park will host the Women’s College World Series from May 29 through June 5/6. But before the fireworks start under those iconic red dirt lights, we’ve got regionals (May 16-18) and super regionals (May 22-25) to sort through—and some serious questions about how the committee came to their conclusions.
Listen here: https://youtu.be/-DFa4F5Mrhc
Let’s break it down.
Top Seeds, Top Questions
Texas A&M earned the No. 1 overall seed; on the surface, there’s no issue. The Aggies bulldozed through the SEC, owned the RPI, and smacked Tennessee 13-2 in the conference tournament. They check every box: dominance, consistency, and big wins when it mattered.
But from there, the bracket starts to feel like a mystery novel with half the pages ripped out.
Florida somehow slid into the No. 3 overall seed despite finishing sixth in the SEC and getting bounced immediately in the conference tournament. Yes, they beat Oklahoma in a regular-season series, and you can bet the committee clung to that like a lifeline, but is one marquee win enough to leapfrog deeper, more complete résumés?
UCLA grabs the No. 9 seed without winning the Big Ten regular season or tournament. Clemson wins the ACC and still gets slotted at No. 11. You’d think a conference title would carry some weight. Tell me it’s all about the TV market, without saying it’s all about the TV market.
Apparently, it doesn’t carry as much as a familiar logo.
Alabama at No. 15? Hosting? That one’s not even a head-scratcher; it’s a full-blown shoulder shrug. There’s no seeding logic, no RPI angle, and no conference résumé to hang that on. It just… is.
Our Take: Résumé ≠ Reputation
Let’s call it what it is, too many of these seeds feel based on brand over body of work.
Take Florida State. They beat Florida, finished higher in the ACC, and came in third in RPI (just behind Florida at No. 2). So, if you’re using RPI as your sword, how do you explain Florida being two seeds higher than a team they lost to?
It gets murkier. Florida is seeded behind Oklahoma, even though the Gators beat them and won the series. So now head-to-head doesn’t matter either?
The RPI is flawed; we all know it. It rewards early overhype and doesn’t self-correct nearly enough. But even if you live and die by RPI, the way it was applied here still makes no sense. It’s selective logic at best.
And then there’s Alabama. There’s no metric, no résumé line, no “eye test” argument that justifies them hosting. That one’s pure reputation play. Legacy over legitimacy.
We’re not saying the committee’s job is easy. But if the results on the field don’t matter, and the numbers only matter when they support a favored narrative, then what exactly are we seeding here?
Rant over, on to the good stuff.
Regional Rundown: Who’s Hot, Who’s Hosed
1. Bryan-College Station Regional
Favorite: Texas A&M
Danger Level: Low
The Aggies drew a soft landing with Liberty, Saint Francis (PA), and Marist. Anything short of a 3-0 cruise would be a surprise.
2. Norman Regional
Favorite: Oklahoma
Danger Level: Medium
The Sooners are still the queens of OKC until someone proves otherwise, but Boston University has a chip on its shoulder, and this isn’t a vintage dominant Oklahoma squad. Losses to Florida, Alabama, and Tennessee show cracks.
3. Gainesville Regional
Favorite: Florida
Danger Level: High
Georgia Tech and Florida Atlantic could cause issues. This is a volatile Gators team—high ceiling, low floor. Keep an eye out.
4. Fayetteville Regional
Favorite: Arkansas
Trap Game: Oklahoma State
Arkansas has the edge, but Oklahoma State is battle-tested and could absolutely steal this regional. Bri Ellis needs to show up big.
5. Tallahassee Regional
Favorite: Florida State
Dark Horse: Auburn
This one has teeth. Florida State’s pitching gives them the edge, but Auburn has the offense to flip the script.
6. Austin Regional
Favorite: Texas
Tough Draw: Michigan
Texas got a rougher path than expected. Michigan and UCF aren’t cupcakes, and Texas hasn’t always handled pressure well.
7. Knoxville Regional
Favorite: Tennessee
Sleeper: Ohio State
Karlyn Pickens gives Tennessee a puncher’s chance deep in the bracket. But Ohio State has quietly put together a solid résumé.
8. Columbia Regional
Favorite: South Carolina
Upset Watch: North Florida
The Gamecocks earned the No. 8 seed behind a gritty SEC season and a top-10 RPI, but this regional is no walk. North Florida is a serious sleeper—45 wins, a top-25 RPI, and one of the best-kept secrets in the ASUN. Virginia brings battle-tested ACC competition, and Elon can scrap. If South Carolina wants to make it out clean, they’ll need to tighten up defensively and find consistent production at the plate.
9. Los Angeles Regional
Favorite: UCLA
Upset Alert: San Diego State
UCLA’s seeding is generous, but their path is not. SDSU is no joke, and Arizona State adds heat. This could implode.
10. Baton Rouge Regional
Favorite: LSU
X-Factor: Nebraska
LSU should win this on talent alone, but Nebraska could be sneaky. UConn won’t go down easy either.
11. Clemson Regional
Favorite: Clemson
Toughest Test: Kentucky
This is a loaded regional. Clemson got snubbed in seeding, but they’ve got a clear edge—if they can get through Northwestern and Kentucky.
12. Lubbock Regional
Favorite: Texas Tech
Key Player: NiJaree Canady
Canady is the real deal. If she’s locked in, Tech advances. No official opponent list yet, but they’re ready for whoever.
13. Tucson Regional
Favorite: Arizona
Upset Watch: Grand Canyon
The Wildcats are back hosting for the first time since 2021 and come in with a 45-11 record and serious pedigree, but don’t sleep on GCU. At 46-6, they’re more than just a mid-major stat pad. Ole Miss brings SEC grit, and Santa Clara’s playing with house money. This one could get weird if Arizona’s offense sputters early.
14. Durham Regional
Favorite: Duke
Upset Watch: Georgia
Georgia isn’t your typical 2-seed, and Coastal Carolina can mash. This one feels unpredictable.
15. Tuscaloosa Regional
Favorite: Alabama
Skeptical: Us
No full bracket info yet, but Alabama doesn’t pass the eye test right now. They’ll need to scrap to get out.
16. Eugene Regional
Favorite: Oregon
Sleeper Run Pick
Don’t sleep on the Ducks. A 19-3 Big Ten record and wins over top contenders make them a prime upset candidate in the supers.
This tournament is ripe for chaos. Texas A&M looks poised to ride their momentum all the way to OKC, but they’re not bulletproof. Florida State and Clemson are both underseeded and hungry, don’t be shocked if one (or both) make a deep push. And if Oregon crashes the party in Oklahoma City? We won’t be the least bit surprised.
Keep an eye on Florida Atlantic. Head coach Jordan Clark and her staff have built a quietly dangerous squad that’s more than capable of wrecking brackets in Gainesville. FAU isn’t just a feel-good story, they’re a dark horse with bite.
As for Florida and UCLA… they’ve got target signs on their backs and brackets that could send them packing early.
Florida softball once again flexes its muscle in the 2025 NCAA Tournament, sending six programs into the field of 64—further cementing the state as one of college softball’s power centers. Florida and Florida State headline as national seeds and regional hosts, while Florida Atlantic and South Florida aim to make noise in those same regionals. UCF, now in the Big 12, heads to Austin with upset intentions, and North Florida, fresh off a 45-win season, is a legitimate threat in a sneaky-tough Columbia Regional. From the big names to the rising programs, the Sunshine State is stacked from top to bottom—and it’s showing up all over the bracket.
So here we are, 64 teams, one golden ticket to Oklahoma City, and a bracket that feels more unpredictable than ever. The top seeds have questions swirling, the underdogs are loaded with bite, and if the past few tournaments have taught us anything, it’s that the chalk rarely survives the weekend. From powerhouse programs like Texas A&M and Oklahoma looking to cement their legacies, to scrappy dark horses like FAU and Oregon ready to crash the party, this tournament has all the makings of a classic. The road to OKC runs through chaos, controversy, and clutch performances, and we wouldn’t have it any other way. Let the madness begin.